navigation bar

Honor Our History, Character, and Community.

 

West Lewis and Falcon Street Mini-Park Project

The proposed West Lewis Street Mini Park project, to be located on the canyon rim area from West Lewis at Goldfinch to West Lewis at Falcon, was discussed at our monthly board meeting April 15, 2009. This project was initially proposed in 2006 and was estimated to cost $280,000. As designs evolved and challenges with the site were found, the price moved to $450,000 and then $630,000, with an unpriced Phase 2 planned. At this time, $450,000 has been allocated by the City, to be paid from the Developer Impact Fund (DIF) for the Uptown Area.

Following a thorough discussion and review of materials related to this proposal, our Board of Directors acknowledged that the residents of the area have spent a great deal of time working to create a public space along this prominent canyon rim that will add to our total community character. Therefore they voted 7-1 to submit a recommendation that the project proceed, but with a spending cap of the already appropriated $450,000, and with modifications to simplify the project. The project requires a Process 3 Site Development Permit, and will go before a Hearing Officer on April 29, 2009 at 8:30 a.m. in the City Council Chambers. Click here for our comment letter to this project.

To read our letter to the City of San Diego regarding this project, click here.

Proposed Heritage Park Plan (Heritage Park Master Plan Improvement)


The Heritage Park project proposes that the County of San Diego enter into an agreement with Pacific Hospitality Group (PHG -- owner and operator of the Hacienda Hotel) to develop and operate Heritage Park for lodging and other purposes. (Heritage Park is located on Juan Street, across from the Hacienda Hotel.) Development includes site improvements and the creation of 84 guest rooms. The 84 units would come from converting six existing Victorian buildings for 21 units and building four new structures to provide 63 units. No new parking is proposed, as the plan utilizes 45 spaces existing at Heritage Park and an additional 41 spaces in the lot controlled by the Hacienda Hotel at the corner of Juan and Harney. The county document includes drawings and an analysis of many possible environmental impacts, all of which are proposed to be “No impact” or “Less than significant impact.”

The entire negative declaration for the Heritage Park Project can be found at: http://www.sdcounty.ca.gov/reusable_components/images/parks/doc/Heritage_Park_ND_IS.pdf

The County Board of Supervisors will be considering this project on April 8, 2009.

Mission Hills Heritage has sent a letter to the County of San Diego Department of Parks and Recreation stating our concerns and comments on the Draft Negative Declaration on the Heritage Park Master Plan Improvement. To read the letter to the County from Mission Hills Heritage, click here. We will continue to monitor this project and provide updates as events unfold.

When the county sets a date for the hearing on this project, they will post a notice on the San Diego County Public Hearing Notices web page.

Historic Districts

What is the purpose of a Historic District?
To maintain, protect and preserve the scale and basic character and salient architectural details of homes within a historical district. A historical district is not a static museum, but rather a living, changing neighborhood. There is room for private renewal and architectural creativity, within appropriate controls and standards. Historical designation in a neighborhood will encourage continuous research into a community's human past and culture for the benefit of future generations and protect our high-quality architecture, mature landscaping and pedestrian orientation of our historic community by denying demolition of existing older homes to simply build out-of-scale super-houses that overwhelm the neighborhood. The character of a neighborhood is threatened by the teardown phenomenon, which is destroying the architecture and heritage of many communities. A historic district will provide protection from demolition, insensitive alterations and out-of-character new construction and emphasize the value of the historic neighborhood.

Existing and Proposed Historic Districts in Mission Hills

Mission Hills Historic District  This district, consisting of 75 homes along the 1800 block of Sunset Blvd, Sheridan Ave. and Lyndon Road, was approved by the Historic Resources Board in July 2007.  The district was appealed, but the City Council upheld the district in January 2008.

Fort Stockton Line Historic District  This district, consisting of 107 homes along parts of Fort Stockton Drive, West Lewis and Pine Street, was approved by the Historic Resources Board in July 2007.  It was not appealed and became effective 10 days later.

Mission Hills Historic District Extension  In March 2008, residents on the blocks between Sunset, Witherby and Fort Stockton formed a committee to explore forming another historic district that had been proposed several years ago.  This proposed district would include 99 homes on portions of Sunset, St. James, Arden Way, Arguello, Hickory, Ingleside, and Whiterby.  Because the proposed district falls entirely within the first Mission Hills Subdivision, Map No. 1115, the City has determined that this district would become an extension of the Mission Hills Historic District.  The City has met with residents on the committee and a preliminary notice has been sent to all affected homeowners in the area.  An informational meeting is in the planning stage, and residents hope to submit the necessary information to bring this district to a hearing in 2009. This extension would “close the gap” between Sunset and Fort Stockton.

The City’s Historical Resources Board has mapped out a larger potential Mission Hills Historic District, based on the entire area of the original Mission Hills subdivision, map number 1115.  This potential district may eventually encompass all of the original Mission Hills subdivision maps recorded in 1908 by George Marston and his partners.  Click here for a map of this larger potential district, which also shows the current boundaries of the Mission Hills Historic District and Fort Stockton Line Historic District.  Other potential historic districts could be approved in Mission Hills, based on various subdivision maps recorded in the early 1900s, covering much of what is currently known as Mission Hills, such as Inspiration Heights, and Presidio Hills.

To learn more about Historic Districts, the Mills Act, the National Secretory of the Interior Standards and the City of San Diego's HRB Historic District website, please click on the following links and websites

Mills Act information:
www.sohosandiego.org/reflections/2002july/millsact.htm

Historic Districts "How they work for the community"
www.sohosandiego.org/reflections/2003-2/histdistricts.htm

Secretory of the Interior Standards:
www.nps.gov/history/hps/tps/standguide/

City of San Diego HRB Historic Districts:
www.sandiego.gov/planning/programs/historical/districts.shtml

SOHO Website: Historic Districts and Mission Hills Historic District Guidelines (not yet adopted)
http://sohosandiego.org/histdistricts/index.htm



Current Projects: 
• Project Review at Uptown Planners
North Mission Hills Historic Lighting
Proposed Interim Ordinance for a Height Restriction in Portions of Uptown and Mission Hills
• Uptown Community Plan Update
• Oral History Nomination


Sites to Watch (if you know of any plans for these sites, please contact us)


Demolished or Destroyed Mission Hills
• 4080 Goldfinch Street (click here for a flyer)

 

Project Review at Uptown Planners
Uptown Planners is the city-recognized community-planning advisory group for the Uptown neighborhoods, which include Mission Hills. Uptown Planners makes recommendations to the City Council, Planning Commission, City staff, and other governmental agencies on land use matters, specifically, concerning land use plans and development projects. Many proposed development projects and other land use matters affecting Mission Hills are heard at the monthly meeting. Uptown Planners meets the first Tuesday of every month at 6:00pm at the Joyce Beers Community Center, (across from Trader Joe’s) 1230 Cleveland Avenue, San Diego, CA. Here is the link to the Uptown Planners website: http://72.41.77.23/index.html. Agendas for monthly meetings and project information are posted on the Uptown Planners website.

 

North Mission Hills Historic Lighting
Many Mission Hills residents have expressed interest in upgrading the street lighting in areas of Mission Hills from “cobra” style lighting to the more historic “acorn” style revival lighting, similar to that found in the Presidio Park area.  The current utility under-grounding project provides a unique opportunity to upgrade lighting and make other street improvements.  Upgrading the lighting and other street improvements will require forming a “maintenance assessment district” (MAD).  Various residents and the city’s underground utility program manager asked Mission Hills Heritage to assist in collecting information about this project. Mission Hills Heritage agreed to assess the interests of the affected residents and how it relates to our streetscape. A meeting was being held on February 1, 2006 at Grant School to learn more about forming a Lighting and Landscape MAD. See a letter to residents in the area for an overview. Please also view a newsletter about the project.

See maps of the proposed undergrounding plans and summaries of the processes from the undergrounding managers' perspective: map 1, map 2, summary 1, summary 2.

Surveys were sent to 574 homes in the North Mission Hills area in early March 2006. Approximately 40% of the households responded to the survey related to adding revival lighting in place of the new cobra lighting planed for the area in conjunction with the under-grounding plan.  Click here for results. Over 70% respondents are in favor of revival lighting using the “acorn style” light fixtures similar to those used in the Presidio area.

The application to form a MAD was submitted in August 2006. Mission Hills Heritage is working with the city to put plans into place that reflect the survey results.

Coordinating the under grounding project with the planning department and Maintenance Assessment district so that the changes to lighting will be cost effective and more attractive takes a lot of effort.  We’d like to thank those who have taken a lead in this project, distributed and completed surveys to assist the process for the neighborhood, and have supported the process.  Additional information meetings will be made available in the coming weeks to go over the process and lighting plans.


Proposed Interim Ordinance for a Height Restriction in Portions of Uptown and Mission Hills

Triggered in part by the City’s approval of a 148’ tall project in the heart of Hillcrest last year, Uptown Planners (the community planning group that advises the City on development matters in the Uptown area) voted in June 2006 to recommend that the San Diego City Council adopt an “interim height ordinance” limiting heights for new construction in the portions of Uptown.  As currently proposed, the ordinance would impose height limits to the following areas:

  • 65 feet on Washington Street from 5th Avenue to Dove, on University Avenue from Park to Front Street, and on portions of 4th, 5th and 6th north of Upas Street, and
  • 50 feet on Washington Street from Dove to Ibis Street.

The current Uptown Community Plan, which provides guidelines for development in our community, was adopted in 1988, and a related zoning zoning ordinance was passed a year later.  The zoning contains provisions for heights up to 150 feet tall (about 14-15 stories) and 200 feet tall (almost 20 stories!) along portions of Washington Street, University Avenue and 4th, 5th and 6th Avenue.  The community plan is now 18 years old. 

Conditions have changed since adoption of the Uptown Community Plan.  In recent years numerous projects have come forward for taller buildings, which many residents and business owners feel overwhelm the character and scale of the existing community.   An update is needed to the community plan so the entire community can re-evaluate these guidelines for future development in Uptown.  The existing plan is overdue for an update.

Pending completion of the update to the community plan and related zoning, the proposed IHO would temporarily limit height on new projects until our community plan and related zoning is updated.  Because this recommendation by Uptown Planners is advisory only, the City Council needs to be made aware of public support for this proposed ordinance!

Uptown Planners conducted an online survey last year with the result that over 80% of those taking the survey supported the proposed ordinance.  In addition, over 1200 Uptown residents and business owners have signed a petition supporting the IHO.  The proposed ordinance is endorsed by various groups, including:

  • Save Our Heritage Organisation (SOHO)
  • Mission Hills B.I.D.
  • Mission Hills Heritage
  • University Heights Community Development Corporation
  • University Heights Historical Society
  • Hillcrest Business Association
  • Hillcrest Town Council
  • Hillcrest Historical Guild

Mission Hills Heritage is helping spearhead the effort to convince the City to adopt the IHO.  Until recently, the City had not responded.  However, in June 2007, the director of the Planning Department indicated the City’s willingness to support some key provisions of the IHO.  Work is now in progress on such an ordinance, although there are various hurdles to be overcome.

Please help show your support for this proposed interim ordinance by signing a petition in support of the ordinance.   

Click here for a copy of the petition. Please return your signed petition to Mission Hills Heritage personnel or mail back to us at our contact address listed below.

A local developer recently circulated an email about the survey which states: “The real question is, do we want short squat buildings (no taller than 2-4 stories along Washington) …”  Since the character of Mission Hills for almost a century has been defined by buildings mostly 1-3 stories, we think the resounding answer is: Yes, 50 feet is more than tall enough!!!


Uptown Community Plan Update

A community plan is a planning document which includes guidelines for development within a specified community. The City of San Diego has about 45 community plans. The existing community plan for Uptown (which includes Mission Hills, Hillcrest, Bankers Hill, and part of University Heights) is about 20 years old, and overdue for updating. The Uptown community plan will be updated as part of a cluster of three community plans, which will include North Park and Golden Hill, and will take about 24-36 months to complete.
The City Planning & Community Investment (CPCI) Department held an informational meeting on January 28, 2009 to discuss the plan update process. The following is an overview of the process:

CPCI, with assistance from contract consultants, will actually draft the plan, with input from special "stakeholder" advisory committees (one for each of the three planning areas), which will consist of members of the local community planning group and other “stakeholders” from the community. It is anticipated that the advisory committee for Uptown will be formed in March 2009. Uptown Planners will chose those members of Uptown Planners that will sit on the committee, and the City will chose the community stakeholders. The process for chosing the stakeholders has not been announced.

Once formed, the advisory commmittees will meet periodically (approximately every 6-8 weeks) during the update process, and will participate in public meetings/workshops facilitated by paid consultants, which will include charettes. It is anticipated that there will be approximately 4-6 such workshops over a several day period. There will also be a "cluster advisory committee" consisting of members from all three planning areas for issues common to all three communities.

The scope of issues that will be the subject of the charettes will vary depending on the community. Issues for Uptown will include: urban design, facilities planning, community character, building heights, public transportation and density issues.

Our community has an opportunity and a challenge to make certain that those aspects of our community that we cherish most are preserved, including our historical homes, buildings and other resources, that our community charm and character is not obliterated by new projects, and to assure that new development harmonizes with the existing community. Mission Hills Heritage intends to participate in the community plan update process and to keep our members and the community at large involved in the process.


Oral History Program
Mission Hills Heritage is pleased to announce the unveiling of its oral history program for its new and renewing members 

Members are eligible to nominate their family and friends for recording an oral history. Interview subjects will have a chance to polish their memories during an interview including scanning old photographs and resulting in a transcript.  Often these histories relate to the neighborhood development or happenings, to friends, families, the broader context of times gone by.  Oral histories often create a record of the everyday events that shaped San Diego history, Conducting oral histories of residents is an enjoyable way for members, residents or former residents to pass along these stories and traditions to future generations. 

The oral histories will be posted here and original records will be donated to the San Diego Historical Society.   Special thanks for Celeste Dunn of Tristany Realty for her generous donation and for sponsoring this program in its inaugural year through April 2007.  Click here for a nomination form.

The first MHH Oral History is available! Click here to read this fascinating interview with our neighbor, World War II Veteran, and distinguished local architect Homer Delawie.

 


How can you help?

  • Keep informed of community projects.
  • Write letters and emails to the Mayor and City Council (information is below).
  • Attend meetings.
  • Volunteer your talent and time to support Mission Heritage goals.
  • Join as a member Mission Hills Heritage, a residents association.
  • Financially contribute to Mission Hills Heritage to fund the expert support we need to be persuasive with both the city and the developer.

 

Voice Your Concerns:
You can also assist us by registering your concerns by contacting the Mayor and members of the City Council.  Please refer to the project name and include your name and address in any communications so that you can be provided notices for any city meetings.  The contact information is as follows:


Mayor
Jerry Sanders
202 C Street, 11th Floor
San Diego, CA 92101
Phone: 619.236.6330
Fax: 619.236.7228
Email: jerrysanders@sandiego.gov


City Council
Council President
Sherri Lightner
202 C Street, MS 10A
San Diego, CA 92101
Phone: 619.236.6611
Email: scottpeters@sandiego.gov

Kevin Faulconer
202 C Street, MS 10A
San Diego, CA 92101
Phone: 619.236.6622
Email: kevinfaulconer@sandiego.gov

Todd Gloria
202 C Street, MS 10A
San Diego, CA 92101
Phone: 619.236.6633
Email: toniatkins@sandiego.gov

Tony Young
202 C Street, MS 10A
San Diego, CA 92101
Phone: 619.236.6644
Email: anthonyyoung@sandiego.gov

Carl DeMaio
202 C Street, MS 10A
San Diego, CA 92101
Phone: 619.236.6655
Email: bmaienschein@sandiego.gov

Donna Frye
202 C Street, MS 10A
San Diego, CA 92101
Phone: 619.236.6616
Email: donnafrye@sandiego.gov

Marti Emerald
202 C Street, MS 10A
San Diego, CA 92101
Phone: 619.236.6677
Email: jmadaffer@sandiego.gov

Ben Hueso
202 C Street, MS# 10A
San Diego, CA 92101
Telephone: 619.236-6688
Email: benhueso@sandiego.gov